2025: Manhattan Voted Emack & Bolio’s Best Ice Cream!
Emack & Bolio’s
389 Amsterdam Ave
(212) 362-2747 – emackandbolios.com
Joy is served by the scoop at Emack & Bolio’s, the 2025 Winner in the Ice Cream category, where creativity and indulgence collide in every cone. Known for its imaginative flavors, colorful toppings, and whimsical presentation, the shop turns classic ice cream into a true work of art. Each batch is made with premium ingredients, resulting in rich, creamy textures and bold, unforgettable tastes. From outrageous sundaes to hand-dipped cones lined with candy and cereal, every treat sparks delight for kids and adults alike. The playful, welcoming atmosphere makes it more than just dessert — it’s an experience that celebrates fun, flavor, and the sweet side of life.
2024: Manhattan Voted Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream Best Ice Cream!
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
2 Rivington St
(212) 209-7684 – morgensternsnyc.com
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream offers gourmet pies, pints, scoops, and other treats inside a New American ice cream shop. Since 2014, sweet-toothed lovers have turned to them to get their fix from a varied menu filled with classic dishes from banana splits and brownie sundaes to decadent cakes and innovative boozy drinks such as the Burnt Honey Daiquiri. Morgenstern’s look to change the way people eat and think about this nostalgic treat by giving ice cream lovers an entirely original and indulgent ice cream experience.
2023: Manhattan Voted Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream Best Ice Cream!
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
2 Rivington St
(212) 209-7684 – morgensternsnyc.com
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream offers gourmet pies, pints, scoops, and other treats inside a New American ice cream shop. Since 2014, sweet-toothed lovers have turned to them to get their fix from a varied menu filled with classic dishes from banana splits and brownie sundaes to decadent cakes and innovative boozy drinks such as the Burnt Honey Daiquiri. Morgenstern’s look to change the way people eat and think about this nostalgic treat by giving ice cream lovers an entirely original and indulgent ice cream experience.
2022: Manhattan Voted Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream Best Ice Cream!
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
2 Rivington St
(212) 209-7684 – morgensternsnyc.com
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream offers gourmet pies, pints, scoops, and other treats inside a New American ice cream shop. Since 2014, sweet-toothed lovers have turned to them to get their fix from a varied menu filled with classic dishes from banana splits and brownie sundaes to decadent cakes and innovative boozy drinks such as the Burnt Honey Daiquiri. Morgenstern’s look to change the way people eat and think about this nostalgic treat by giving ice cream lovers an entirely original and indulgent ice cream experience.
2021: Manhattan Voted Sugar Hill Creamery Best Ice Cream!
Sugar Hill Creamery
184 Malcolm X Blvd
(212) 634-9004 –
2020: Manhattan Voted Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream Best Ice Cream!
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream
2 Rivington St
(212) 209-7684 – www.morgensternsnyc.com
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream offers gourmet pies, pints, scoops, and other treats inside a New American ice cream shop. Since 2014, sweet-toothed lovers have turned to them to get their fix from a varied menu filled with classic dishes from banana splits and brownie sundaes to decadent cakes and innovative boozy drinks such as the Burnt Honey Daiquiri. Morgenstern’s look to change the way people eat and think about this nostalgic treat by giving ice cream lovers an entirely original and indulgent ice cream experience.
