2025: Manhattan Voted Toloache Best Tex-Mex Restaurant in Manhattan!
Toloache
251 West 50th Street
(212) 581-1818 – toloachenyc.com
Bold flavors and vibrant energy take center stage in this 2025 Winner for Tex-Mex, celebrated for its creative twist on classic Mexican cuisine. Toloache brings an elevated dining experience that fuses traditional recipes with modern flair, captivating guests through color, spice, and authenticity. Known for its inventive dishes, handcrafted margaritas, and warm, lively atmosphere, the restaurant embodies the true spirit of culinary innovation. Each plate showcases fresh ingredients and masterful technique, reflecting a passion for both heritage and artistry. With its commitment to excellence and an unforgettable blend of taste and presentation, this acclaimed destination continues to redefine Tex-Mex dining, offering an experience that is as bold, flavorful, and dynamic as the city itself.
2024: Manhattan Voted Flats Fix Taco Y Tequila Bar Best Tex-mex!
Flats Fix Taco Y Tequila Bar
28 E 16th St
(917) 435-0515 – flatsfix.com
Got a taste for some tacos and tequila? Crave no more! Flats Fix Taco Y Tequila Bar is at your service. Open seven days a week, closing between 11 pm and 1 am for foodies wanting a tex-mex fix before enjoying more of the night life that New York City has to offer, walk-ins and those who prefer to reserve seating are always invited and welcome! If you want more than just tacos, Flats Fix features an extensive menu, including quesadillas, burritos, tortas and an array of salads and bowls, along with selected spirits, Mexican beers and of course, tequila! Wondering where the name of the restaurant originated? After you’re seated and place your order, don’t forget to ask your server!
2023: Manhattan Voted Burritos Y Mas NY Best Tex-mex!
Burritos Y Mas NY
1571 Lexington Ave
(718) 679-4605 – grubhub.com/restaurant/burritos-y-mas-1571-lexington-ave-new-york/331371
You don’t have to travel to either Texas or Mexico to enjoy some quality Tex-Mex cuisine, because Burritos Y Mas NY has it all! Quite literally meaning “burritos and more,” Burritos Y Mas NY has everything you can think of — all different types of burritos including vegetarian options, quesadillas, nachos, taco salads, soups, chilis, empanadas, desserts, and a “Special of the Day” which gives you a new option daily! Located on 1571 Lexington Avenue, Burritos Y Mas NY is easy to get to, but probably hard to leave because you’ll want to try everything! From their grilled steak burrito, to their grilled chicken burrito, to their vegetarian seitan burrito and their other options, there’s no shortage of menu items that’ll make you a repeat customer.
2022: Manhattan Voted 118 Kitchen Best Tex-mex!
118 Kitchen
1 E 118th St
118 Kitchen is the premier place for Tex-Mex in New York City. If you’re looking for a quick bite, or you’re out on the town with friends, 118 Kitchen has you covered with their extensive menu of tacos, burritos, empanadas, quesadillas and more! Plus, of course, their drinks are authentic, and great too. This isn’t some fancy-smancy place, they only focus on delivering you the best food you’ll find in the Tex-Mex arena. And best yet, it won’t hurt your wallet, as their prices are fair, and the best bank-for-your-buck that you’ll find!
2021: Manhattan Voted Toloache Best Tex-Mex!
Toloache
251 W 50th Street
(212) 581-1818 – http://www.toloachenyc.com
The toloache is a flowering plant famous in Mexico for its use in love potions. And New Yorkers love the contemporary Tex-Mex creations served up at this midtown Manhattan bistro (and Upper East Side location) named after that plant by chef-owner Julian Medina. Toloache’s menu of mouth-watering fare includes such favorites as tacos, quesadillas and enchiladas. But they are far from your run-of-the-mill versions of those dishes. For example, the taco varieties include Suadero, which comes with braised brisket, avocado, red onions, cilantro, tomatillo, salsa and horseradish crema. Then there’s the Costilla Y Tuetano made with beef short ribs. Plus, there’s freshly-made guacamole in your choice of mild, medium or spicy. So corral your friends or loved ones together for lunch or dinner here soon!
2020: Manhattan Voted Cowgirl SeaHorse Best Tex-Mex!
Cowgirl SeaHorse
259 Front St
(212) 608-7873 – www.cowgirlseahorse.com
Are you a fan of Tex-Mex? Of course you are, and that’s why you should get to know Cowgirl SeaHorse, a laid back restaurant where you can find your favorite Southwestern dishes with a unique seafood twist. Cowgirl opened up its doors in 2009, with the leadership of Sherry Delamarter, who possesses over 30 years of restaurant experience in the city. In addition to its inventive menu — with standout items like their Blackened Fish, cheesy Enchiladas and Sausage and Biscuits, Cowgirl SeaHorse also has fun themed-days for customers to take advantage of their specials. The restaurant, with its nautical setting, invites customers to visit them on Taco Tuesdays and Music Mondays where they invite local musicians to play live.
