new york city
Best of Food & Drink / Lobster Roll - 2026

Luke’s Lobster Union Square

Follow Luke’s Lobster Union Square

See All Wins

2026

Lobster Roll

  • Best Lobster Roll Winner

    Luke’s Lobster specializes in seafood rolls built around lobster, crab and shrimp. The classic lobster roll features chilled lobster meat dressed simply and served in a toasted split-top bun, while other rolls rotate among crab and shrimp preparations. If you’re feeling indecisive, you can order a Lobster Flight, which is available for a limited time; the flight allows you to sample several different rolls in miniature. The menu also includes lobster bisque, seafood sides and other New England-inspired items. Luke’s sources seafood from fishing communities and has built its brand around connecting diners with the coastal foods associated with Maine and the Northeast. The Union Square shop offers a casual way to enjoy fresh, flavorful seafood.

2025

Lobster Roll

  • Best Lobster Roll Winner

    Freshness, simplicity, and flavor come together perfectly in every bite at this award-winning seafood spot. Honored as the 2025 Winner in the Lobster Roll category, Luke’s Lobster Union Square has mastered the art of serving sustainably sourced, Maine-style lobster rolls that capture the true essence of coastal dining. Each roll is crafted with chilled, wild-caught lobster, lightly dressed with lemon butter, and nestled in a perfectly toasted bun — no frills, just pure flavor. Guests praise the restaurant’s dedication to quality ingredients, ocean-friendly practices, and warm, welcoming service that make every visit memorable. Whether enjoyed on a lunch break or a weekend outing, their lobster rolls offer a taste of Maine in the heart of the city.

2024

Lobster Roll

  • Best Lobster Roll Winner

    Oh, lobster rolls! They are so very delicious. But if you’re looking for where to get the absolute best lobster roll in New York City, there is only one place to check out: Luke’s Lobster in Union Square! This delicious roll is served Maine-style, chilled with a bit of mayo, lemon butter and Luke’s very own secret seasoning. By the way, this ever-popular seafood joint offers a whole bunch of other yummy rolls, too, including the shrimp roll and Jonah crab roll. For an extra fun and flavorful experience, try Luke’s lobster roll flight, a sampler of three 2-oz half-rolls in lemon butter, spicy honey butter and truffle butter, served with chips and a drink. You can’t lose with anything you choose at Luke’s. It’s all exquisite!

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES